12 445 167 views
Battlefield 1 Weapon comparison: M1911 vs SMLE MKIII Carbine
Symthic BF1 stats version
1.08
Notice

Weapons that show "N/A" for all reload values have dynamic reload times. See reload mechanics page for more information.

!

Weapon 1

VS
Weapon
Attachment 1
Attachment 2

Weapon 2

Apply attachment changes

M1911
+ None + None
vs
SMLE MKIII Carbine
+ None + None
Advantages of M1911 + None + None
Much higher fire rate
299 rpm
vs
52 rpm
M1911 fires rounds 475% faster
Significatly less recoil to left
0.7
vs
1
M1911 has 30% less kick to left
Significatly less recoil to right
0.7
vs
1
M1911 has 30% less kick to right
Faster Recoil decrease
5
vs
3
M1911 recovers 67% faster from recoil
Significantly less spread (HIP, Stand, Not moving)
0.8
vs
1.667
M1911 has 52% lower HIP base spread (Standing, Not moving)
Slightly less spread (HIP, Crouching, Not moving)
0.8
vs
1.334
M1911 has 40% lower HIP base spread (Crouch, Not moving)
Slightly less spread (HIP, Prone, Not moving)
0.8
vs
1.001
M1911 has 20% lower HIP base spread (Prone, Not moving)
Significantly less spread (HIP, Stand, Moving)
1.2
vs
2.668
M1911 has 55% lower HIP base spread (Standing, Moving)
Significantly less spread (HIP, Crouching, Moving)
1.2
vs
2.335
M1911 has 49% lower HIP base spread (Crouch, Moving)
Significantly less spread (HIP, Prone, Moving)
1.2
vs
2.001
M1911 has 40% lower HIP base spread (Prone, Moving)
Significantly less spread increase per shot (HIP)
0.2
vs
1
Spread increases 80% less on M1911 when shooting (HIP)
Much quicker to fire after switching weapons
0.55 s
vs
0.9 s
M1911 has 39% faster firing after weapon switch
Advantages of SMLE MKIII Carbine + None + None
Much more max damage
100
vs
35
SMLE MKIII Carbine has 186% higher max damage
Much more min damage
80
vs
15
SMLE MKIII Carbine has 433% higher min damage
Bigger magazine
10
vs
8
SMLE MKIII Carbine has 25% bigger magazine
Much higher muzzle velocity
740 m/s
vs
250 m/s
SMLE MKIII Carbine's bullets fly 196% faster
Significatly less upwards recoil
2
vs
2.3
SMLE MKIII Carbine has 13% less upwards kick
Significantly less spread (ADS, not moving)
0
vs
0.4
SMLE MKIII Carbine has 100% lower ADS base spread (Not moving)
Significantly less spread increase per shot (ADS)
0
vs
0.2
Spread increases 100% less on SMLE MKIII Carbine when shooting (ADS)
A bit faster spread decrease (HIP)
6.7
vs
6
SMLE MKIII Carbine recovers 12% faster from spread (HIP)
Equal stats on M1911 + None + None and SMLE_MKIII_Carbine + None + None
Equal bullet drop
12 m/s²
vs
12 m/s²
Both guns have same bullet drop
Same first shot recoil multiplier
1 x
vs
1 x
Both guns have same first shot recoil multiplier
Same amount of spread (ADS, moving)
0.5
vs
0.5
Both guns have same amount of ADS spread (Moving)
Same first shot spread multiplier (HIP)
1
vs
1
Both guns have same first shot spread multiplier (HIP)
Same first shot spread multiplier (ADS)
1
vs
1
Both guns have same first shot spread multiplier (ADS)
Same number of pellets
1
vs
1
Both guns fire equal amount of pellets
Same pellet cone spread
0
vs
0
Both guns have same pellet spread
9.2670917510986